• About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Friday, June 27, 2025
Unitedpac St Lucia News - Header Logo
  • St Lucia News
  • News
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    Allen Chastanet takes a photo with students from the St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025

    St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025: Allen Chastanet Salutes

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Concrete truck and motorcycle at the scene of Bexon fatal motorcycle crash

    Bexon fatal motorcycle crash: 1 dead after concrete truck collision

    Ernest Hilaire and brother Paul Hilaire linked to Bananes payout scandal

    Bananes payout scandal: Was Hilaire’s brother the mastermind?

    Darby Ettiene found dead in Black Bay pictured in white shirt and sunglasses

    Darby Ettiene Found Dead in Black Bay with Throat Slashed

    Trending Tags

    • Government of Saint Lucia
    • Saint Lucia Crime News
    • Saint Lucia Agriculture News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    Composite image of Tinubu and Philip J Pierre used in coverage of Tinubu visit to St Lucia

    Tinubu visit to St Lucia triggers airport shutdown outrage

    Bola Tinubu and Philip J Pierre pictured together amid backlash as St Lucia shuts airports for Nigerian president

    Outrage as St Lucia Shuts Airports for Nigerian President Tied to Drug Scandal

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Nicole David dies at 51 after cancer battle, Saint Lucia mourns soca icon

    Devastating Loss: Nicole David Dies at 51 After Cancer Battle

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Aerial view of Point Hardy Golf Club’s dramatic cliffside green at Cabot St Lucia, ranked among Golfweek’s Top 5 international courses.

    Cabot St Lucia Debuts in Golfweek Top 5 for Point Hardy Golf Club

    Trending Tags

    • Julien Alfred
    • West Indies Cricket
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
    Air India Flight 171 crash wreckage with tail debris and crowd in Ahmedabad

    Air India Flight 171 Crash Kills 242 in Ahmedabad

    Cover of the St Lucia tourism slide report showing Piton backdrop and beach resort – April 2025

    St Lucia tourism slide deepens amid government inaction

    Trump travel ban 2025 with U.S. State Department seal and American flag

    Trump Travel Ban: Sweeping New Restrictions on 19 Nations

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Illustration of a young St Lucian looking through a gate, symbolizing how St Lucians are opting out due to lack of opportunity.

    Why St Lucians are opting out: economic collapse fuels exodus

    US embassy visa warning over Caribbean birth tourism misuse shown with close-up of visa.

    US Embassy visa warning targets Caribbean birth tourism

    Trending Tags

    • OKEU Hospital
    • Saint Lucia Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
No Result
View All Result
  • St Lucia News
  • News
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    Allen Chastanet takes a photo with students from the St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025

    St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025: Allen Chastanet Salutes

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Concrete truck and motorcycle at the scene of Bexon fatal motorcycle crash

    Bexon fatal motorcycle crash: 1 dead after concrete truck collision

    Ernest Hilaire and brother Paul Hilaire linked to Bananes payout scandal

    Bananes payout scandal: Was Hilaire’s brother the mastermind?

    Darby Ettiene found dead in Black Bay pictured in white shirt and sunglasses

    Darby Ettiene Found Dead in Black Bay with Throat Slashed

    Trending Tags

    • Government of Saint Lucia
    • Saint Lucia Crime News
    • Saint Lucia Agriculture News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    Composite image of Tinubu and Philip J Pierre used in coverage of Tinubu visit to St Lucia

    Tinubu visit to St Lucia triggers airport shutdown outrage

    Bola Tinubu and Philip J Pierre pictured together amid backlash as St Lucia shuts airports for Nigerian president

    Outrage as St Lucia Shuts Airports for Nigerian President Tied to Drug Scandal

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Nicole David dies at 51 after cancer battle, Saint Lucia mourns soca icon

    Devastating Loss: Nicole David Dies at 51 After Cancer Battle

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Aerial view of Point Hardy Golf Club’s dramatic cliffside green at Cabot St Lucia, ranked among Golfweek’s Top 5 international courses.

    Cabot St Lucia Debuts in Golfweek Top 5 for Point Hardy Golf Club

    Trending Tags

    • Julien Alfred
    • West Indies Cricket
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
    Air India Flight 171 crash wreckage with tail debris and crowd in Ahmedabad

    Air India Flight 171 Crash Kills 242 in Ahmedabad

    Cover of the St Lucia tourism slide report showing Piton backdrop and beach resort – April 2025

    St Lucia tourism slide deepens amid government inaction

    Trump travel ban 2025 with U.S. State Department seal and American flag

    Trump Travel Ban: Sweeping New Restrictions on 19 Nations

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Illustration of a young St Lucian looking through a gate, symbolizing how St Lucians are opting out due to lack of opportunity.

    Why St Lucians are opting out: economic collapse fuels exodus

    US embassy visa warning over Caribbean birth tourism misuse shown with close-up of visa.

    US Embassy visa warning targets Caribbean birth tourism

    Trending Tags

    • OKEU Hospital
    • Saint Lucia Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
No Result
View All Result
Unitedpac St Lucia News - Mobile Logo
  • St Lucia News
  • News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
Home News Justice

Allen Chastanet Secures Victory in Bid to Appeal at CCJ

Allen Chastanet secures victory as the Court of Appeal grants leave to escalate the Rovergate case to the Caribbean Court of Justice, raising critical legal and constitutional questions.

Unitedpac by Unitedpac
November 29, 2024
in Politics, Justice, Local News
Reading Time: 5 mins read
142 3
A A
0
Allen Chastanet and Ernest Hilaire pictured during the ongoing Rovergate case, where Allen Chastanet secures victory in legal proceedings.

Allen Chastanet and Ernest Hilaire pictured

32
SHARES
322
VIEWS
Share Share Reddit

Table of Contents

  • 1. Background of the Case
  • 2. Key Issues for the CCJ
  • 3. Broader Implications
  • 4. Political Ramifications
  • 5. What’s Next?

Allen Chastanet Secures Victory as Court Grants Leave to Appeal High-Profile Case to CCJ.

ST. LUCIA – A legal showdown that has gripped the nation took a dramatic turn this week, as Allen Chastanet Secures Victory in his bid to escalate a high-profile legal case to the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), marking a pivotal moment in St. Lucia’s legal landscape. The Court of Appeal granted Allen Chastanet leave to appeal a long-standing legal dispute involving the Comptroller of Customs Sherman Emmanuel, highlighting constitutional and legal issues of significant public interest.

The decision represents a major step forward for Allen Chastanet, who has been at the forefront of the ongoing legal battle stemming from the withdrawal of charges against Dr. Ernest Hilaire by the Customs Department. Chastanet argued that the case raises critical constitutional questions that merit the CCJ’s consideration, and the Court of Appeal agreed, acknowledging that these issues have far-reaching implications for public accountability and the rule of law.

01
of 05
Background of the Case

The case originated during the tenure of Acting Comptroller of Customs Peter Chiquot, who initiated charges against Ernest Hilaire, a prominent political figure, for failing to provide documentation of ownership for a vehicle. However, following a change in administration, Customs Comptroller Sherman Emmanuel, Peter Chiquot’s successor, withdrew the charges just two months after the 2021 general elections.

Comptroller of Customs Sherman Emmanuel in uniform during the Rovergate case as Allen Chastanet secures victory in legal proceedings.
Comptroller of Customs Sherman Emmanuel in uniform

The decision to withdraw the charges sparked intense scrutiny and raised questions about the integrity of public office and prosecutorial discretion. In response, Allen Chastanet filed for judicial review of the Comptroller’s decision to discontinue the case. His request for leave to seek judicial review was initially denied by the High Court and upheld by the Court of Appeal.

02
of 05
Key Issues for the CCJ

Unwavering in his pursuit of justice, Allen Chastanet appealed to the Court of Appeal for leave to escalate the matter to the CCJ. The Court of Appeal agreed, stating that the proposed appeal involved significant constitutional and legal issues warranting the CCJ’s input. Among the critical questions to be addressed are:

  1. Implied Powers of Discontinuance: Whether the Court of Appeal was correct in concluding that the power to discontinue charges could be implied under the Interpretation Act and the Constitution.
  2. Judicial Review Standards: Whether the standard for judicial review of the Comptroller of Customs’ prosecutorial discretion should align with the standards applied to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP).
  3. DPP’s Role in the Case: Whether the Court of Appeal and the lower court erred in finding that the DPP had not taken over the prosecution of Hilaire.
  4. Constitutional Powers of the DPP: Whether it is arguable that the DPP had assumed constitutional responsibility for the prosecution, making it the DPP’s sole authority to withdraw charges.

The Court of Appeal emphasized that these issues hold profound implications for public accountability, constitutional law, and the exercise of prosecutorial discretion by statutory authorities.

03
of 05
Broader Implications

Legal observers have hailed the decision as a pivotal moment in the so-called “Rovergate” saga, which has come to symbolize broader questions of transparency and accountability in public office. Chastanet and his supporters argue that ensuring ethical conduct and adherence to the rule of law is essential for maintaining public trust in St. Lucia’s institutions.

 TM Antoine Partners building with Ernest Hilaire's Range Rover in focus, central to the Rovergate case where Allen Chastanet secures victory.
TM Antoine Partners building with Ernest Hilaire’s Range Rover in focus, central to the Rovergate case

“The integrity of public office fosters confidence in institutions and protects the public interest,” Chastanet said in a statement following the ruling. “The rule of law must apply to everyone equally, regardless of their position or influence.”

04
of 05
Political Ramifications

The case has also reignited political tensions between Allen Chastanet’s United Workers Party (UWP) and the ruling Saint Lucia Labour Party (SLP). The UWP has positioned itself as a staunch advocate for ethical leadership and has repeatedly criticized what it perceives as a lack of accountability in the current administration.

In a statement, the UWP reaffirmed its commitment to ensuring that no one, including those in public office, is above the law. The party described the Court of Appeal’s ruling as a step toward restoring public confidence and reinforcing the principles of justice and fairness.

05
of 05
What’s Next?

The CCJ will now be tasked with examining the constitutional and legal arguments presented in the appeal. The court’s eventual ruling could set a precedent for how prosecutorial discretion is exercised and reviewed in St. Lucia and across the region.

As the case moves to the region’s highest court, the spotlight will remain on the critical balance between the independence of statutory functionaries and the need for public accountability. For now, Allen Chastanet’s victory at the Court of Appeal underscores the enduring importance of these issues to St. Lucia’s legal and political landscape.

Follow Unitedpac St. Lucia News for the latest updates on this developing story.

Tags: Allen Chastanet legal victoryCaribbean Court of Justice appealChastanet vs. Comptroller of Customsconstitutional law St. LuciaErnest Hilaire corruption scandalErnest Hilaire Range Rover caseRovergate caseSt. Lucia Court of AppealUWP stance on integrity

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

SLP Slammed for Shocking CIP Deal with Criminal Developer

Next Post

The Richard Frederick Travel Adventure: Will We Witness a Brutal Cinderella Ending?

Related Posts

Composite image of Tinubu and Philip J Pierre used in coverage of Tinubu visit to St Lucia

Tinubu visit to St Lucia triggers airport shutdown outrage

June 27, 2025
242
Bola Tinubu and Philip J Pierre pictured together amid backlash as St Lucia shuts airports for Nigerian president

Outrage as St Lucia Shuts Airports for Nigerian President Tied to Drug Scandal

June 26, 2025
1.9k
Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

June 25, 2025
4.4k
Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

June 19, 2025
241
Concrete truck and motorcycle at the scene of Bexon fatal motorcycle crash

Bexon fatal motorcycle crash: 1 dead after concrete truck collision

June 14, 2025
3.2k
Ernest Hilaire and brother Paul Hilaire linked to Bananes payout scandal

Bananes payout scandal: Was Hilaire’s brother the mastermind?

June 14, 2025
655
Next Post
Richard Frederick travel adventure continues with a cheerful moment captured in New York, highlighting his ongoing globetrotting lifestyle.

The Richard Frederick Travel Adventure: Will We Witness a Brutal Cinderella Ending?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Stay Connected

  • 22.4k Fans
  • 873 Followers
  • 13.5k Subscribers
  • 2.6k Followers
  • 41 Followers
  • 2.3k Followers
ADVERTISEMENT

Top Stories

Darby Ettiene found dead in Black Bay pictured in white shirt and sunglasses

Darby Ettiene Found Dead in Black Bay with Throat Slashed

June 12, 2025 - Updated on June 13, 2025
988
Kunta dies suddenly in Gros Islet; photo shows Stephen “Kunta” William days before his unexpected death on Chapel Street.

Kunta Dies Suddenly in Gros Islet; Body Found on Chapel Street

June 12, 2025
1k
Denver Felix was fatally shot during Marchand violence on Sunday, June 8, 2025

Marchand Violence Leaves 1 Dead, 1 Injured Weekend Attack

June 12, 2025
592
Air India Flight 171 crash wreckage with tail debris and crowd in Ahmedabad

Air India Flight 171 Crash Kills 242 in Ahmedabad

June 12, 2025
452
Unitedpac St. Lucia News logo

Unitedpac St Lucia News is Saint Lucia's leading online source for St Lucia news, breaking news, and top stories, with updates from the Caribbean, US, and around the world. Our platform offers in-depth coverage of local events, government, business, sports, and culture, paired with daily videos that bring Saint Lucia's vibrant scenery and community to life. We are committed to delivering reliable, engaging news and sharing stories that matter most to our readers. Stay connected with Unitedpac St Lucia News for updates that inform and inspire.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Business
  • Commentary
  • Entertainment
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
  • News
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
  • Politics
  • Press Releases
  • Tech
  • World

Recent News

Composite image of Tinubu and Philip J Pierre used in coverage of Tinubu visit to St Lucia

Tinubu visit to St Lucia triggers airport shutdown outrage

June 27, 2025
Bola Tinubu and Philip J Pierre pictured together amid backlash as St Lucia shuts airports for Nigerian president

Outrage as St Lucia Shuts Airports for Nigerian President Tied to Drug Scandal

June 26, 2025
Allen Chastanet takes a photo with students from the St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025

St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025: Allen Chastanet Salutes

June 26, 2025
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 Unitedpac St Lucia News - All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • St Lucia News
  • News
    • Agriculture
    • Local News
    • Justice
    • Crime
    • Caribbean News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    • Education
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Saint Lucia Events
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Travel
    • Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases

Copyright © 2025 Unitedpac St Lucia News - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.