• About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Thursday, June 26, 2025
Unitedpac St Lucia News - Header Logo
  • St Lucia News
  • News
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    Allen Chastanet takes a photo with students from the St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025

    St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025: Allen Chastanet Salutes

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Concrete truck and motorcycle at the scene of Bexon fatal motorcycle crash

    Bexon fatal motorcycle crash: 1 dead after concrete truck collision

    Ernest Hilaire and brother Paul Hilaire linked to Bananes payout scandal

    Bananes payout scandal: Was Hilaire’s brother the mastermind?

    Darby Ettiene found dead in Black Bay pictured in white shirt and sunglasses

    Darby Ettiene Found Dead in Black Bay with Throat Slashed

    Trending Tags

    • Government of Saint Lucia
    • Saint Lucia Crime News
    • Saint Lucia Agriculture News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Nicole David dies at 51 after cancer battle, Saint Lucia mourns soca icon

    Devastating Loss: Nicole David Dies at 51 After Cancer Battle

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Aerial view of Point Hardy Golf Club’s dramatic cliffside green at Cabot St Lucia, ranked among Golfweek’s Top 5 international courses.

    Cabot St Lucia Debuts in Golfweek Top 5 for Point Hardy Golf Club

    Jady Emmanuel crosses the finish line to win 100m sprint gold for Saint Lucia at CARIFTA 2025

    Jady Emmanuel makes history: Double gold for St Lucia at CARIFTA

    Emrand Matthew deepens Dennery SLP divide with Facebook outburst

    Explosive Dennery SLP Divide? Fond D’Or Jazz Shakeup Sparks Infighting

    Trending Tags

    • Julien Alfred
    • West Indies Cricket
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
    Air India Flight 171 crash wreckage with tail debris and crowd in Ahmedabad

    Air India Flight 171 Crash Kills 242 in Ahmedabad

    Cover of the St Lucia tourism slide report showing Piton backdrop and beach resort – April 2025

    St Lucia tourism slide deepens amid government inaction

    Trump travel ban 2025 with U.S. State Department seal and American flag

    Trump Travel Ban: Sweeping New Restrictions on 19 Nations

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Illustration of a young St Lucian looking through a gate, symbolizing how St Lucians are opting out due to lack of opportunity.

    Why St Lucians are opting out: economic collapse fuels exodus

    US embassy visa warning over Caribbean birth tourism misuse shown with close-up of visa.

    US Embassy visa warning targets Caribbean birth tourism

    Trending Tags

    • OKEU Hospital
    • Saint Lucia Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
No Result
View All Result
  • St Lucia News
  • News
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    Allen Chastanet takes a photo with students from the St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025

    St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025: Allen Chastanet Salutes

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

    Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Concrete truck and motorcycle at the scene of Bexon fatal motorcycle crash

    Bexon fatal motorcycle crash: 1 dead after concrete truck collision

    Ernest Hilaire and brother Paul Hilaire linked to Bananes payout scandal

    Bananes payout scandal: Was Hilaire’s brother the mastermind?

    Darby Ettiene found dead in Black Bay pictured in white shirt and sunglasses

    Darby Ettiene Found Dead in Black Bay with Throat Slashed

    Trending Tags

    • Government of Saint Lucia
    • Saint Lucia Crime News
    • Saint Lucia Agriculture News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

    Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

    Nicole David dies at 51 after cancer battle, Saint Lucia mourns soca icon

    Devastating Loss: Nicole David Dies at 51 After Cancer Battle

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Aerial view of Point Hardy Golf Club’s dramatic cliffside green at Cabot St Lucia, ranked among Golfweek’s Top 5 international courses.

    Cabot St Lucia Debuts in Golfweek Top 5 for Point Hardy Golf Club

    Jady Emmanuel crosses the finish line to win 100m sprint gold for Saint Lucia at CARIFTA 2025

    Jady Emmanuel makes history: Double gold for St Lucia at CARIFTA

    Emrand Matthew deepens Dennery SLP divide with Facebook outburst

    Explosive Dennery SLP Divide? Fond D’Or Jazz Shakeup Sparks Infighting

    Trending Tags

    • Julien Alfred
    • West Indies Cricket
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
    Air India Flight 171 crash wreckage with tail debris and crowd in Ahmedabad

    Air India Flight 171 Crash Kills 242 in Ahmedabad

    Cover of the St Lucia tourism slide report showing Piton backdrop and beach resort – April 2025

    St Lucia tourism slide deepens amid government inaction

    Trump travel ban 2025 with U.S. State Department seal and American flag

    Trump Travel Ban: Sweeping New Restrictions on 19 Nations

    Sulphur Springs mineral baths in Soufriere as Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise

    Sulphur Springs and Jetty Fees to Rise: SRDF Announces New Visitor Rates

    Illustration of a young St Lucian looking through a gate, symbolizing how St Lucians are opting out due to lack of opportunity.

    Why St Lucians are opting out: economic collapse fuels exodus

    US embassy visa warning over Caribbean birth tourism misuse shown with close-up of visa.

    US Embassy visa warning targets Caribbean birth tourism

    Trending Tags

    • OKEU Hospital
    • Saint Lucia Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
No Result
View All Result
Unitedpac St Lucia News - Mobile Logo
  • St Lucia News
  • News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
Home News Justice

Caribbean Galaxy Subpoena Efforts Quashed: Legal Battle Intensifies

Court Quashes Caribbean Galaxy Subpoenas, Setting Legal Precedents for International Discovery

Unitedpac by Unitedpac
June 10, 2024 - Updated on July 2, 2024
in Caribbean News, Justice
Reading Time: 3 mins read
122 1
A A
0
MRS Media CEO Philippe Martinez with a Logo of Caribbean Galaxy Subpoena Efforts Ruling
27
SHARES
273
VIEWS
Share Share Reddit

Table of Contents

  • 1. The Court’s Authority and the Legal Context
  • 2. Caribbean Galaxy’s Argument and Court’s Response
  • 3. Judicial Prudence and Emphasis on Evidence
  • 4. Future Implications

Court Quashes Caribbean Galaxy Subpoenas, Setting New Legal Precedents

In a significant development, the legal wrangling between Caribbean Galaxy and multiple financial institutions has taken a critical turn. On April 29, 2024, Caribbean Galaxy filed a Motion to Quash Applicants’ Subpoena to JP Morgan Chase Bank, followed by a similar motion against subpoenas to Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation, The Bank of New York Mellon, BNY Mellon N.A., and Standard Chartered International USA. These Caribbean Galaxy subpoena motions were met with resistance and led to a detailed court ruling outlining the implications and future directions of the case.

01
of 04
The Court’s Authority and the Legal Context

The district court’s authority to grant applications for judicial assistance under 28 U.S.C. § 1782 has been a focal point in this legal saga. The law grants the court the power to permit discovery for use in proceedings before foreign or international tribunals. However, this authority comes with strict compliance requirements, as highlighted by the Applicants’ alleged failure to adhere to Rule 45(a)(4).

The court’s order, dated February 8, 2024, highlighted two primary concerns:

  1. The Applicants’ failure to comply with Rule 45(a)(4).
  2. The court’s apprehensions about the scope of the discovery permitted.

These concerns formed the basis for the court’s decision to quash the Caribbean Galaxy subpoenas issued to JP Morgan Chase Bank and other financial institutions.

02
of 04
Caribbean Galaxy’s Argument and Court’s Response

Caribbean Galaxy’s motions to quash were rooted in arguments similar to those presented in challenging the Bank of America subpoena. The company argued that the subpoenas should be quashed for the same reasons and on similar grounds as the previous motions. However, the court was not persuaded by these arguments.

The court’s response was clear: the information sought could not be used in the defamation proceedings. The court noted that the St. Kitts and Nevis courts would not permit discovery to request information from Movant or any third party to support defamatory allegations against Movant at the time of publication.

03
of 04
Judicial Prudence and Emphasis on Evidence

The court underscored the importance of judicial prudence in dealing with evidence from foreign tribunals. In referencing previous cases, the court emphasized that it would decide whether additional evidence is admissible, ensuring that the discovery process is appropriately managed.

The court’s general practice, in cases of genuine dispute over the ultimate admissibility of § 1782 evidence, has been to allow discovery to proceed. This was illustrated by the reference to the 2018 case (Torres, Maj. J.), which noted that the Spanish Court should decide the admissibility of evidence.

04
of 04
Future Implications

The court’s ruling sets a precedent for how discovery requests under § 1782 are to be handled, particularly when there is potential for abuse or overreach in the discovery process. By quashing the Caribbean Galaxy subpoenas and vacating the previous order, the court has made it clear that it will not tolerate procedural non-compliance and speculative fishing expeditions.

In the final lines of the document, the court explicitly put Caribbean Galaxy on notice, stating that while they are free to challenge any future § 1782 Application the Applicants may file, the court is not persuaded by the “for use” contentions advanced thus far. This highlights the court’s commitment to ensuring that discovery processes are not misused and that all parties adhere strictly to legal protocols.

This ruling is a critical reminder of the stringent standards governing international judicial assistance and the court’s role in safeguarding the integrity of the discovery process. As the legal battle continues, Caribbean Galaxy and other involved parties must navigate these complexities with utmost diligence and adherence to judicial norms.


For further updates on this case and more legal news, stay tuned to Unitedpac St. Lucia.

Tags: Caribbean GalaxyCourt RulingJP Morgan ChaseMSR MediaSt. Kitts and Nevis CourtsSubpoena Quashed

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Rodney Bay Double Homicide: Probe Launched by Royal Saint Lucia Police Force

Next Post

Ernest Hilaire CIP Scandal: Speaker Defends Ernest Hilaire, Throws CIP CEO Under the Bus

Related Posts

Gavel with crime scene tape in background, symbolizing Loic Augustin charged with murder in Marigot homicide case

Loic Augustin Charged With Murder in Marigot Homicide Case

May 25, 2025 - Updated on May 26, 2025
613
US embassy visa warning over Caribbean birth tourism misuse shown with close-up of visa.

US Embassy visa warning targets Caribbean birth tourism

May 24, 2025
551
Teri Helenese at the CMEx Leadership Awards 2024 in D.C., highlighting her role in Virgin Islands colonial injustice advocacy.

Fierce call to end Virgin Islands colonial injustice

May 23, 2025
236
Hands of arrested man in handcuffs after Port Castries drug and gun bust

British national charged in Port Castries drug and gun bust

May 22, 2025
1.1k
Volunteers participate in Blue Lagoon Island Earth Day cleanup on Nassau's coast

Blue Lagoon Island leads Earth Day beach cleanup in Nassau

May 22, 2025
182
Evidence including handcuffs, cash, and laptop seized in Creators Alliance crackdown in St Lucia

Creators Alliance Crackdown: St Lucia Arrests Key Suspects

May 22, 2025
869
Next Post
Ernest Hilaire, Claudius Francis, and Mc Claude Emmanuel stand together with the majestic Pitons of Saint Lucia in the background, highlighting the Ernest Hilaire CIP scandal.

Ernest Hilaire CIP Scandal: Speaker Defends Ernest Hilaire, Throws CIP CEO Under the Bus

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Stay Connected

  • 22.4k Fans
  • 873 Followers
  • 13.5k Subscribers
  • 2.6k Followers
  • 41 Followers
  • 2.3k Followers
ADVERTISEMENT

Top Stories

Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

June 25, 2025
3.9k
Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

June 19, 2025
241
Concrete truck and motorcycle at the scene of Bexon fatal motorcycle crash

Bexon fatal motorcycle crash: 1 dead after concrete truck collision

June 14, 2025
3.2k
Ernest Hilaire and brother Paul Hilaire linked to Bananes payout scandal

Bananes payout scandal: Was Hilaire’s brother the mastermind?

June 14, 2025
653
Unitedpac St. Lucia News logo

Unitedpac St Lucia News is Saint Lucia's leading online source for St Lucia news, breaking news, and top stories, with updates from the Caribbean, US, and around the world. Our platform offers in-depth coverage of local events, government, business, sports, and culture, paired with daily videos that bring Saint Lucia's vibrant scenery and community to life. We are committed to delivering reliable, engaging news and sharing stories that matter most to our readers. Stay connected with Unitedpac St Lucia News for updates that inform and inspire.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • Business
  • Commentary
  • Entertainment
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
  • News
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
  • Politics
  • Press Releases
  • Tech
  • World

Recent News

Allen Chastanet takes a photo with students from the St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025

St Lucia School of Innovation Class of 2025: Allen Chastanet Salutes

June 26, 2025
Conway man shot in Anse Ger and injured in Desruisseaux vehicle crash

Conway man shot in Anse Ger, injured again in Desruisseaux crash

June 25, 2025
Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 football team celebrates 2025 championship win

Saint Lucia Sports Academy U-16 Triumphs in Championship

June 19, 2025
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2025 Unitedpac St Lucia News - All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • St Lucia News
  • News
    • Agriculture
    • Local News
    • Justice
    • Crime
    • Caribbean News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    • Education
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Saint Lucia Events
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Travel
    • Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases

Copyright © 2025 Unitedpac St Lucia News - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.