Table of Contents
Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Programme Faces Criticism and Calls for Reform
The recent press release issued by the Government of Saint Lucia in response to the lawsuit filed by Philippe Martinez and associated companies is a feeble attempt to deflect accountability and obscure the egregious misconduct under its Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program (CIP).
01
of 08Evasion of Core Issues
First and foremost, the government’s denial of any business with Philippe Martinez is a blatant evasion of the core issues at hand. It is public knowledge that Caribbean Galaxy Real Estate Limited has operated with impunity under the watchful eyes of Saint Lucian officials, including Prime Minister Philip Pierre, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister responsible for the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Programme, Ernest Hilaire, Chairman of the Board Lorne Theophilus, and CIP CEO Mr. Mc Claude Emmanuel. The attempt to disassociate from the fraudulent activities in Saint Kitts & Nevis while ignoring similar patterns of corruption within its own borders is disingenuous at best.
02
of 08Questionable Integrity of CIP Leadership
The press release lauds Mr. Emmanuel’s “commendable and ethical” performance. However, the facts tell a different story. Caribbean Galaxy has continued to manipulate the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program, underselling shares and compromising the integrity of the program. The historical context provided conveniently omits the persistent issues of underpricing and lack of transparency, which have been a hallmark of Caribbean Galaxy’s operations from the start.
03
of 08The Canelles Project Smokescreen
The timeline provided regarding the Canelles Project is another smokescreen. While the government highlights the initiation and construction milestones, it fails to address the fundamental problem: the project was a vehicle for unethical practices, allowing Caribbean Galaxy to bypass due diligence and sell citizenship at discounted rates. The mere commencement of construction does not absolve the administration of its responsibility to ensure fair and legal transactions within the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program.
04
of 08Hollow Declarations Against Discounting Practices
Furthermore, the government’s repeated declarations against discounting practices ring hollow. Actions speak louder than words, and the continuous involvement of Caribbean Galaxy in the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program, despite widespread allegations of malpractice, undermines any credibility these statements might hold. It is a poorly veiled attempt to placate international scrutiny while doing little to address the systemic corruption that plagues the program.
05
of 08Transparent Effort to Distance from Scandal
The assertion that Saint Lucia has no part in the contractual obligations or grievances between MSR Media and the Government of Saint Kitts & Nevis is a transparent effort to distance itself from a scandal that implicates its own officials. The reality is that the same corrupt entity, Caribbean Galaxy, operates in both jurisdictions, exploiting weaknesses in governance and oversight to its advantage. Saint Lucia’s attempt to dissociate itself is not only unconvincing but also indicative of a broader culture of denial and deflection.
06
of 08Misplaced Confidence in CIP Leadership
Finally, the vow to defend the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program’s reputation against “false and malicious attacks” is laughable. The reputation of the CIP Unit has already been tarnished by its own actions, or rather, its inactions. The government’s confidence in those leading the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program, especially Minister Ernest Hilaire, Lorne Theophilus, and Mc Claude Emmanuel, is misplaced and demonstrates a troubling disregard for accountability and ethical governance.
07
of 08The Final Analysis
The Government of Saint Lucia’s press release is nothing more than a hollow defense mechanism, devoid of substance and accountability. It fails to address the core issues of corruption and malpractice within the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program, and instead, resorts to deflection and denial. The international community and investors deserve better than these weak attempts at damage control. It is time for the government to take genuine responsibility and implement meaningful reforms to restore integrity to the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program.
08
of 08Background and Analysis
In light of the press release dated May 25, 2024, the Government of Saint Lucia attempts to distance itself from allegations tied to Philippe Martinez and associated entities. This stance appears disingenuous, particularly considering the documented interactions with Caribbean Galaxy Real Estate Limited and the known involvement of high-ranking officials in overseeing and facilitating these business operations. The timeline provided by the government glosses over critical points where due diligence was evidently neglected, and the persistent underpricing practices were allowed to continue unchecked. This raises serious questions about the commitment to transparency and accountability within the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program.
As such, it is imperative for the government to not only acknowledge these oversights but to also take decisive action to rectify the systemic issues that have been allowed to fester within the Saint Lucia Citizenship by Investment Program framework. Only through such measures can Saint Lucia hope to restore faith in its investment programs and assure the international community of its dedication to ethical governance.
