• About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • LIVE TV
Friday, August 15, 2025
Unitedpac St Lucia News - Header Logo
  • St Lucia News
  • All News
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    Photo of Chris Lionel with fiancée at a public event, second Marchand shooting victim dies after July attack.

    Second Marchand Shooting Victim Dies Weeks After Hospital Wedding

    Removed yellow UWP party flags lying on the ground in Dennery North as the Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism.

    Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism of party flags

    Erin storm update showing forecast track and wind speeds as the system moves toward the northern Leeward Islands in August 2025

    Erin storm update: System heads toward northern Leeward Islands

    Depiction of Port Castries cannabis seizure with marijuana packages and “dried fruit” tins, August 2025

    Port Castries Cannabis Seizure: $51K Worth of Marijuana Found in Drug Bust

    Illustration for news story on US Visa Restrictions showing State Department seal, medical worker silhouettes, and flags of Cuba, Grenada, and Africa.

    US Visa Restrictions Hit Cuban, African, and Grenadian Officials

    Forecast track of Tropical Storm Erin showing projected path toward the Caribbean

    Tropical Storm Erin strengthens, tracks toward the Caribbean

    Trending Tags

    • Government of Saint Lucia
    • Saint Lucia Crime News
    • Saint Lucia Agriculture News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    • Video News
    Jason Holder hits the winning shot in thrilling West Indies T20 victory over Pakistan in Florida

    Jason Holder Heroics End West Indies T20 Losing Streak

    Hulk Hogan flexing in red Hulkamania shirt before crowd – Hulk Hogan dead at 71

    Hulk Hogan dead at 71 after suffering cardiac arrest

    Nadine J Joseph-Collins, who spoke out on the St Lucia calypso judging controversy

    St Lucia calypso judging controversy: Labour supporter speaks out

    Sherman Augustin stabbed to death during Carnival in Vigie, pictured in green FC football uniform

    Sherman Augustin stabbed to death in Vigie on Carnival Monday

    Mongstar hospitalized following Monchy shooting ahead of Saint Lucia Carnival Parade

    Mongstar hospitalized following Monchy shooting

    Stock image of police car with flashing lights and crime scene tape used to illustrate RSLPF Castries Operation amid gun violence crackdown.

    RSLPF Castries Operation Nets Illegal Guns Amid Crime Wave

    Trending Tags

    • Julien Alfred
    • West Indies Cricket
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
    Commercial airplane flying low over Caribbean waters, symbolizing improved Caribbean air connectivity through CTO–ASM partnership

    Caribbean air connectivity gets boost with CTO, ASM partnership

    United Airlines aircraft on the tarmac during operational disruptions caused by the United Airlines technical issue and FAA ground stop

    United Airlines technical issue causes major flight delays

    Jennifer Matarangas King pictured, nominated as USVI Tourism Commissioner

    Jennifer Matarangas King tapped to lead USVI Tourism

    Hand holding a Saint Lucia passport by airplane window, symbolizing St Lucia US visa overstay rate issue.

    St Lucia US visa overstay rate highlights deepening economic crisis

    A close-up of a US visa stamp inside a passport, illustrating the US visa bond pilot targeting B-1 and B-2 travelers.

    Costly US visa bond pilot hits B-1/B-2 travelers with $15K rule

    Saint Lucia passport and U.S. visa application form on American flag background, illustrating the end of the US visa interview waiver.

    St Lucia Pays the Price as US Visa Interview Waiver Ends Under Pierre

    Trending Tags

    • OKEU Hospital
    • Saint Lucia Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
No Result
View All Result
  • St Lucia News
  • All News
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    Photo of Chris Lionel with fiancée at a public event, second Marchand shooting victim dies after July attack.

    Second Marchand Shooting Victim Dies Weeks After Hospital Wedding

    Removed yellow UWP party flags lying on the ground in Dennery North as the Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism.

    Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism of party flags

    Erin storm update showing forecast track and wind speeds as the system moves toward the northern Leeward Islands in August 2025

    Erin storm update: System heads toward northern Leeward Islands

    Depiction of Port Castries cannabis seizure with marijuana packages and “dried fruit” tins, August 2025

    Port Castries Cannabis Seizure: $51K Worth of Marijuana Found in Drug Bust

    Illustration for news story on US Visa Restrictions showing State Department seal, medical worker silhouettes, and flags of Cuba, Grenada, and Africa.

    US Visa Restrictions Hit Cuban, African, and Grenadian Officials

    Forecast track of Tropical Storm Erin showing projected path toward the Caribbean

    Tropical Storm Erin strengthens, tracks toward the Caribbean

    Trending Tags

    • Government of Saint Lucia
    • Saint Lucia Crime News
    • Saint Lucia Agriculture News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    • Video News
    Jason Holder hits the winning shot in thrilling West Indies T20 victory over Pakistan in Florida

    Jason Holder Heroics End West Indies T20 Losing Streak

    Hulk Hogan flexing in red Hulkamania shirt before crowd – Hulk Hogan dead at 71

    Hulk Hogan dead at 71 after suffering cardiac arrest

    Nadine J Joseph-Collins, who spoke out on the St Lucia calypso judging controversy

    St Lucia calypso judging controversy: Labour supporter speaks out

    Sherman Augustin stabbed to death during Carnival in Vigie, pictured in green FC football uniform

    Sherman Augustin stabbed to death in Vigie on Carnival Monday

    Mongstar hospitalized following Monchy shooting ahead of Saint Lucia Carnival Parade

    Mongstar hospitalized following Monchy shooting

    Stock image of police car with flashing lights and crime scene tape used to illustrate RSLPF Castries Operation amid gun violence crackdown.

    RSLPF Castries Operation Nets Illegal Guns Amid Crime Wave

    Trending Tags

    • Julien Alfred
    • West Indies Cricket
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
    Commercial airplane flying low over Caribbean waters, symbolizing improved Caribbean air connectivity through CTO–ASM partnership

    Caribbean air connectivity gets boost with CTO, ASM partnership

    United Airlines aircraft on the tarmac during operational disruptions caused by the United Airlines technical issue and FAA ground stop

    United Airlines technical issue causes major flight delays

    Jennifer Matarangas King pictured, nominated as USVI Tourism Commissioner

    Jennifer Matarangas King tapped to lead USVI Tourism

    Hand holding a Saint Lucia passport by airplane window, symbolizing St Lucia US visa overstay rate issue.

    St Lucia US visa overstay rate highlights deepening economic crisis

    A close-up of a US visa stamp inside a passport, illustrating the US visa bond pilot targeting B-1 and B-2 travelers.

    Costly US visa bond pilot hits B-1/B-2 travelers with $15K rule

    Saint Lucia passport and U.S. visa application form on American flag background, illustrating the end of the US visa interview waiver.

    St Lucia Pays the Price as US Visa Interview Waiver Ends Under Pierre

    Trending Tags

    • OKEU Hospital
    • Saint Lucia Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
No Result
View All Result
Unitedpac St Lucia News - Mobile Logo
  • St Lucia News
  • All News
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
  • LIVE TV
Home Commentary

St Lucia calypso judging controversy: Labour supporter speaks out

Unitedpac by Unitedpac
July 24, 2025
in Politics, Commentary, Culture, Saint Lucia Events
Reading Time: 8 mins read
843 8
A A
0
Nadine J Joseph-Collins, who spoke out on the St Lucia calypso judging controversy

Labour supporter Nadine J Joseph-Collins has called for reforms to protect the integrity of Saint Lucia’s calypso competitions.

189
SHARES
1.9k
VIEWS
Share Share Reddit

Nadine J Joseph-Collins urges reforms to protect calypso from political influence in Saint Lucia

CASTRIES, St Lucia — The St Lucia calypso judging controversy has triggered national debate following a forceful public statement from Nadine J Joseph-Collins, a lifelong supporter of the Saint Lucia Labour Party. In a candid and detailed commentary, Nadine J Joseph-Collins warns that political interference is undermining the integrity of one of the island’s most cherished cultural traditions.

Tourism Minister Ernest Hilaire and Carnival Chair Tamara Gibson at Lucian Carnival 2025
Tourism Minister Ernest Hilaire (right) and Carnival Chair Tamara Gibson (left) are among officials prominently involved in Lucian Carnival 2025

Published in full below, her statement outlines the historical roots and social value of calypso as an Afro-Caribbean art form and calls for sweeping reforms to restore public confidence in the fairness of national competition judging. Her critique has resonated with many across the political spectrum who believe calypso’s role as social commentary must remain free from political influence.

ADVERTISEMENT

COMMENTARY BY NADINE J JOSEPH-COLLINS

I know I should not be writing this article, but I feel compelled to say something…

I am a lifelong supporter of the Saint Lucia Labour Party and someone who grew up in a Labour household. I am also a Christian, raised in the Seventh-Day Adventist faith. That upbringing shaped my values of justice and fair play, which continue to guide me today.

ADVERTISEMENT

Alongside those values, our home was rich with cultural traditions. One of my favorites as a child was our annual tradition of watching the Calypso finals. Those moments opened my eyes to the beauty and depth of our cultural art form and planted a lifelong appreciation for Calypso’s power to entertain, educate, and provoke thought.

Through decades of observation, I have witnessed calypso serve its sacred purpose: as social commentary that brings critical issues to light in a palatable way, as dramatic storytelling that captures the essence of our lived experiences, and most importantly, as freedom of expression. But recent events have compelled me to speak out about what I perceive as disturbing trends that threaten to destroy the very soul of this precious cultural treasure.

To understand what is at stake, we must first appreciate what calypso truly represents. Calypso is an Afro-Caribbean musical tradition that emerged in Trinidad and Tobago in the mid-19th Century. Born from the West African Kaiso tradition, calypso began as a tool of communication among enslaved African peoples, a way to circumvent language barriers imposed by their captors and later to denounce oppression through coded lyrics.

More than just festive music, calypso remains a living testimony of Afro-descendant creativity, resistance, and memory. As cultural historians note, “The soul of calypso lies in its stories…Each verse carries a testimony—from the everyday joys of life to sharp critiques of exploitation and inequality”.

Over time, Calypso evolved into what many scholars call “the people’s newspaper”. The calypsonian became the “narrator” and “interpreter of events,” simultaneously functioning as both reporter and editor. This tradition positioned the calypsonian as “the critic of the status quo, in particular those at the top who are charged with navigating the ship of state”.

In Saint Lucia’s context, the National Calypso Monarch Competition celebrates this essence with “sharp social commentary, humor, and captivating performances”. The competition serves as a forum where the island’s top calypsonians showcase their “lyrical mastery, wit, and storytelling prowess”.

According to the official judging criteria published by the Carnival Planning and Management Committee, St Lucia calypso competitions are evaluated based on clearly defined standards. Lyrics, Music and Performance are the big three categories, with lyrics carrying 40 points, and music and performance each worth 30 points.

Within the lyrics category, judges must assess:

  • Theme/Expression/Content (6 points)
  • Wordcraft (16 points)
  • Composition (12 points)
  • Creativity (6 points)

The criteria specifically state that “the lyrics effectively articulate an unambiguously identifiable theme” and that “there is a smooth transition between the verses and chorus depicting the theme via a logical sequence of events”.

These criteria, now available to the public, provide the framework that should govern all judging decisions. The transparency of these standards is crucial for maintaining public trust in the competition’s integrity.

However, my years of observation have raised serious concerns about influences that go beyond these published criteria. The presence of government ministers, the Prime Minister, or other influential political figures in positions where they can be seen by judges creates an environment ripe for perceived bias.

Recent allegations by calypsonian Calixte “Kakal” Xavier are particularly troubling. Xavier claims there was “an orchestrated heckling conspiracy” at calypso tents, with “certain party operatives” asking people to “come in the red shirt and to j at any calypsonians that does not sing in their favor”. Such accusations, whether proven or not, highlight how political considerations can poison the atmosphere of what should be pure artistic competition.

This is not a problem unique to Saint Lucia. Across the Caribbean, similar concerns persist. In Trinidad and Tobago, “the show and its precursor, Calypso Fiesta, have frequently been mired in controversy over claims of bias in the adjudication process”. In Guyana, the government has actually banned calypso songs from state airwaves when lyrics became too critical of corruption.

Dominica faces similar challenges, where the “unfair judging” sentiment has become “as familiar as the calypso tunes themselves”. Even with training workshops for judges, officials acknowledge that “we still don’t have total control over what the judges actually do on the night of the competition”.

Here lies the crux of my concern: Would Labour supporters be comfortable with such allegations of political influence if they were directed at a United Workers Party (UWP) administration? The answer, honestly, should be a resounding no.

The United Workers Party (UWP), which has governed Saint Lucia for significant periods since the 1960s, would rightfully be criticized if similar accusations surfaced during their tenure. Political interference in cultural competitions is wrong regardless of which party holds power. Democracy only thrives when cultural institutions remain independent of political pressure.

The Saint Lucia Labour Party, founded in 1950 to represent “the working class (mainly descendants of African slaves)”, has historically stood for justice and fairness. These same principles should extend to protecting the integrity of our cultural competitions.

When political considerations influence calypso judging, we risk destroying the art form’s fundamental purpose. St Lucia Calypso has been a vital means of expression, and indeed rebellion throughout Caribbean history. By using “double entendre” slaves poked fun at plantation owners and communicated in something close to a secret language.

This tradition of speaking truth to power, of being the “voice of the voiceless,” becomes meaningless if calypsonians must self-censor based on political calculations. Research shows that when governments attempt to control calypso, “many calypsonians have begun to practise self-censorship, and both the artistes and the politicians are using the calypso for political expediency”.

The consequences extend far beyond individual competitions. As one study notes, “if we have an outpouring of such situations, this can be very detrimental to the Calypso art form and the sustenance of the Calypso genre”. We risk creating an environment where genuine artistic expression is replaced by politically safe performances that lack the bite and authenticity that make calypso special. Which is what I found to be a major problem this year.

Several reforms could help restore confidence in our calypso competitions:

  1. Enhanced Transparency: Following the example suggested by calypsonian “Mistah Shak” in Trinidad, scores should be “publicly displayed immediately after their performance, as with athletes at the Olympics” to prevent tampering.
  2. Judge Selection Reform: Implementing systems like those suggested in Dominica, where experienced and less experienced judges are drawn from separate pools, could reduce perceptions of favoritism.
  3. Political Neutrality Zones: Government officials, regardless of party affiliation, should maintain appropriate distance from judging areas during competitions to avoid any appearance of influence.
  4. Post-Competition Accountability: As suggested by calypso analysts, there should be “post-mortem where judges should be held accountable and responsible for the decisions that they make”.

Why? Because the stakes are higher than politics.

This issue transcends party politics. Whether under Labour or UWP leadership, the integrity of our cultural competitions must be protected. Calypso serves as a resource for cultural resistance and social progress. When we allow political considerations to influence judging, we undermine this vital function.

As someone who has watched St Lucia calypso finals for decades, who understands both its entertainment value and its deeper social significance, I cannot remain silent when I perceive threats to its integrity. The art form that taught me about social justice, that gave voice to the voiceless, that brought our community together year after year, deserves better.

The criteria exist. They are published and available to all. Judges should follow them without consideration of who wrote the song, what political party the calypsonian supports, or which government officials might be watching. This is not too much to ask.

Our calypso tradition, rooted in resistance and truth-telling, must remain a space where freedom of expression reigns supreme. Anything less dishonors the legacy of those enslaved ancestors who first used music to speak truth to power, and threatens to rob future generations of this vital cultural inheritance.

The time has come for all Saint Lucians, regardless of political affiliation, to stand up for the integrity of our cultural competitions. The soul of our art form hangs in the balance.

NOTE: This article incorporates research from various published sources about calypso history and competition guidelines.

Public pressure mounts over St Lucia calypso judging controversy

Nadine J Joseph-Collins’ public critique has intensified calls for greater transparency and independence in cultural judging processes. Her decision to speak out as a committed Saint Lucia Labour Party supporter signals growing discomfort within the party’s own base regarding the influence of political operatives on artistic expression.

With public trust hanging in the balance, the St Lucia calypso judging controversy is likely to remain a flashpoint for cultural and political accountability throughout the Carnival season and beyond.

For more cultural commentary, political insight, and trusted reporting, follow Unitedpac St Lucia News, your source for news that informs and empowers.

Tags: calypso judging biascalypso judging controversycalypso monarch competitioncarnival politics st luciacultural integrity st lucialabour supporter speaks outnadine joseph-collins commentarypolitical influence in culturest lucia calypso 2025st lucia carnival reform

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Sherman Augustin stabbed to death in Vigie on Carnival Monday

Next Post

Hulk Hogan dead at 71 after suffering cardiac arrest

Related Posts

Removed yellow UWP party flags lying on the ground in Dennery North as the Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism.

Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism of party flags

August 15, 2025
196
Illustration for news story on US Visa Restrictions showing State Department seal, medical worker silhouettes, and flags of Cuba, Grenada, and Africa.

US Visa Restrictions Hit Cuban, African, and Grenadian Officials

August 13, 2025
597
Philip J Pierre delivers statement on crime policy, with Office of the Prime Minister seal in background.

Philip J Pierre Defends Crime Policy, Accuses Opposition of Politicising Violence

August 12, 2025
233
Jamaican Prime Minister Andrew Holness speaks to reporters during the Jamaica general election 2025 campaign

Jamaica general election 2025 set for September 3 in high-stakes race

August 11, 2025
185
Archbishop Gabriel Malzaire pictured responds to St Lucia buggery law ruling

St Lucia buggery law decriminalized, archbishop responds

August 9, 2025 - Updated on August 10, 2025
428
US reward for Nicolas Maduro arrest hits $50 million as he walks with Saint Lucia PM Philip J Pierre

US reward for Nicolas Maduro arrest soars to record $50 million bounty

August 7, 2025 - Updated on August 8, 2025
536
Next Post
Hulk Hogan flexing in red Hulkamania shirt before crowd – Hulk Hogan dead at 71

Hulk Hogan dead at 71 after suffering cardiac arrest

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Stay Connected

  • 22.4k Fans
  • 873 Followers
  • 13.5k Subscribers
  • 2.6k Followers
  • 41 Followers
  • 2.3k Followers
ADVERTISEMENT

Top Stories

Erin storm update showing forecast track and wind speeds as the system moves toward the northern Leeward Islands in August 2025

Erin storm update: System heads toward northern Leeward Islands

August 14, 2025
529
Depiction of Port Castries cannabis seizure with marijuana packages and “dried fruit” tins, August 2025

Port Castries Cannabis Seizure: $51K Worth of Marijuana Found in Drug Bust

August 14, 2025
780
Forecast track of Tropical Storm Erin showing projected path toward the Caribbean

Tropical Storm Erin strengthens, tracks toward the Caribbean

August 13, 2025
1.2k
Police vehicle and officers secure the crime scene in Wiltons Yard fatal shooting that left 1 dead and 1 injured in St Lucia.

Wiltons Yard Fatal Shooting: 1 Dead, 1 Injured in St Lucia Crime Surge

August 12, 2025
522
Unitedpac St. Lucia News logo

Your trusted source for breaking developments, crime, politics, tourism, and community reporting. Explore live coverage in our St Lucia News section.

Follow Us

Browse by Category

  • All News
    • Agriculture
    • Caribbean News
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Justice
    • Local News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
  • Business
  • Commentary
  • Entertainment
    • Saint Lucia Events
    • Sports
    • Video News
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Health
    • Travel
  • Politics
  • Press Releases
  • Tech
  • World

Recent News

Photo of Chris Lionel with fiancée at a public event, second Marchand shooting victim dies after July attack.

Second Marchand Shooting Victim Dies Weeks After Hospital Wedding

August 15, 2025
Removed yellow UWP party flags lying on the ground in Dennery North as the Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism.

Dennery North UWP condemns vandalism of party flags

August 15, 2025
Erin storm update showing forecast track and wind speeds as the system moves toward the northern Leeward Islands in August 2025

Erin storm update: System heads toward northern Leeward Islands

August 14, 2025
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • LIVE TV

Copyright © 2025 Unitedpac St Lucia News - All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • St Lucia News
  • All News
    • Agriculture
    • Local News
    • Justice
    • Crime
    • Caribbean News
    • Obituary
    • Religion
    • Weather Alerts
    • Education
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Saint Lucia Events
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • Travel
    • Health
  • Tech
  • Commentary
  • Press Releases
  • LIVE TV

Copyright © 2025 Unitedpac St Lucia News - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.