St. Lucia Tourism Crisis: A Critical Review of Ministerial Missteps

01

of 01

Commentary by James Stanislaus

The Emperor’s New Clothes: A Minister’s Delusional Stewardship of St. Lucia’s Tourism Industry

“The recent comments made by Tourism Minister Dr. Ernest Hilaire starkly illustrate the St. Lucia tourism crisis, highlighting the government’s profound incompetence in managing this critical economic sector. Since taking office, Dr. Hilaire has overseen a troubling decline in both airlift from key markets in the UK and USA and a severe reduction in cruise ship port calls—an unprecedented two-year drought between May and October.

Dr. Hilaire’s claim that tourism in St. Lucia benefits only a select few is not merely inaccurate; it underscores his significant misunderstanding of the sector’s widespread economic impact. Contrary to his statements, the tourism industry is a substantial livelihood source for thousands of Saint Lucians, both directly and indirectly, creating a broad economic ripple effect that benefits numerous local businesses and contributes significantly to the country’s GDP.

Reflecting on Aristotle’s philosophy, ‘We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit,’ it becomes evident that incompetence has regrettably become synonymous with Dr. Hilaire’s tenure. The government’s limited focus on events tourism has only exacerbated the St. Lucia tourism crisis, neglecting broader sector needs and leading to infrastructure strain, environmental issues, and social discontent.

Moreover, the Caribbean Tourism Organization has pointed out that St. Lucia is among the few Caribbean destinations not to have rebounded to pre-COVID-19 tourism arrival figures, a clear indicator of the government’s failure to revitalize the industry. The government’s piecemeal approach, overly reliant on community tourism, fails to address the structural weaknesses of the sector.

Interestingly, today, over 2,000 locally owned Airbnb rooms in St. Lucia outnumber traditional hotel accommodations, offering a more direct benefit from tourism for many locals. This shift not only provides diverse lodging options for visitors but also enriches the tourist experience with genuine local culture.

To address the ongoing St. Lucia tourism crisis, the government must reassess its policies and priorities with a focus on:

1. Airlift Development: Enhancing negotiations with airlines to boost frequency and capacity and investing in airport infrastructure.
2. Infrastructure Development: Upgrading the road network to improve accessibility across the island, benefiting both tourists and residents.
3. Marketing and Promotion: Crafting a comprehensive marketing strategy that positions St. Lucia as an appealing year-round destination.
4. Product Diversification: Encouraging the development of varied tourism products and experiences.
5. Community Tourism: Embedding community tourism within a larger strategy, providing necessary resources and training.
6. Education and Training: Developing the tourism workforce to support industry growth.
7. Ease of Doing Business: Streamlining bureaucratic processes and offering entrepreneurial incentives.
8. Access to Financing: Facilitating better financing options for tourism entrepreneurs.
9. Capacity Building for Produce and Service Providers: Enhancing the capabilities of local suppliers to meet industry standards and keep more revenue within the local economy.

As Mark Twain aptly noted, ‘Incompetence is the hallmark of the unworthy.’ It is high time for Minister Hilaire to recognize and rectify his government’s failures in managing the St. Lucia tourism crisis. The people of St. Lucia deserve a government that is accountable and capable of turning around this vital industry.”